Percy Brasco?.

[eggplant9998]

No: HPFGUIDX 121562


"Steve" <bboyminn at y...> wrote:

> [speaking of Marietta] in the end it
> all worked out; no harm, no foul.

If it wasn't for Marietta Dumbledore would still be headmaster when 
Harry had his dream and he wouldn't have been tricked into going to 
the ministry and Sirius would still be alive. 

> Percy hasn't caused any harm. Lots of
> hard feelings, but no realharm. 

If Percy has done less harm than Umbridge it's because he has less 
power than Umbridge. It's clear to me that if Percy had his way both 
Harry and Dumbledore would be in Azkaban. Give him enough power and 
he'll be as bad as any Death Eater, don't be blinded by the man's 
last name.

> Percy did a bad thing, but that 
> doesn't make him a bad person. 

A bad person is someone who does more bad things than good things. 
Except for about 2 seconds during the second task in GoF where Percy 
showed some concern for Ron I can't think of anything good Percy 
ever did in his life, but I can think of lots and lots of bad things.

> That leaves room for redemtion and forgiveness. 

If Percy jumps in front of Harry and takes a bullet for him then 
I'll admit I was wrong and forgive him, but short of that Harry 
would be a fool to EVER trust Percy again.

> I don't think Hermione intended for the 
> Centaurs to kill Umbridge.

It would not lower my very high opinion of Hermione one bit if she 
did expect the Centaurs to kill Umbridge, that foul woman deserved 
to die. 

Eggplant