Ahha!! I've got it... Time-turner not a quick fix

finwitch finwitch at yahoo.com
Sun Jan 16 14:07:50 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 122070


A-Mac:
 
> Harry can not go back in time and save Sirius because Sirius IS 
> dead. If Harry were to go back and save him, we would have seen the 
> affects of it. Unless Harry is somehow hiding to catch Sirius 
before 
> he falls into the veil, and hide him from his past self, it is 
> impossible for Harry to go back and save Sirius. 

Finwitch:

Yes, well: Harry *Can* be invisible. He does have that cloak, 
remember? And er - I think the cloak would be enough to hide Sirius, 
too.

Or maybe Sirius did it? (You know, he was saved by himself because he 
was saved by himself- like Harry in the Dementor-attack).

Or - maybe Sirius did NOT fall trough the veil, only seemed to. And 
if Lupin's the one who shot the stunner, he'd certainly be surprised 
about it. And why would Lupin do that, you ask? Well, to make 
everyone *believe* Sirius is dead, (including PP& other Death Eaters, 
the Ministry- so Kingsley is freed from tracking Sirius etc. 
Unfortunately, also Harry.) of course. 

Being presumed dead would give Sirius freedom (although, he's not to 
be seen in human form until Pettigrew is safely captured). He could 
be of more use, and if he - under this cover, manages to capture the 
Rat, he can lift it and gain formal freedom within the non-DE-wizards.

Finwitch







More information about the HPforGrownups archive