All about Lupin

pippin_999 foxmoth at qnet.com
Tue Jan 18 23:04:26 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 122321


I think we've established that Lupin did not continue to practice 
with Harry until Harry could produce a patronus in the presence 
of a boggart-dementor. Harry warns his class  that they are not  
prepared, even though some of them can do a corporeal 
patronus, and says that  they really need to be practicing with a 
boggart. Harry seems to have forgotten that he didn't get to that 
point with Lupin himself. So did I, until I re-read PoA. Jo is tricky!

  
> Renee:
> That only strengthens the case for Lupin's confession to DD. 
After Sirius told him all about the Animagi transformations, DD 
knew what went on right under his nose, back in the Marauders' 
days. So, if  Lupin had kept this information from him, DD would 
definitely *not*  have said to Harry that Remus told him 
everything. 

Pippin:
Okay, now I'm confused. Where does Dumbledore say that 
Remus told him everything?

Pippin







More information about the HPforGrownups archive