Snape as the one who won't return (Was: In Defense of Snape (VERY long)

[M.Clifford]

No: HPFGUIDX 122347


> > Tammy:
> >
> > And if you remember, when Harry and Dumbledore are trying to
> convince Fudge that what Harry saw was real, Harry starts naming
> names. When Harry first starts, it says this about Snape: "Snape
> made a sudden movement, but as Harry looked at him, Snape's eyes
> flew back to Fudge." Now it could be that reaction was simply
> because his "friend" Lucius had just been named. Or it could have
> been that Snape was afraid that Harry had recognized Snape in the
> graveyard.
> > -Tammy.
>
>
> Tonks here:
> I think it fits. Not sure 100%, but it
> is possible. I often thought that of the 3 that were not there,
> Snape was not one of the list. I think that there is another one
> somewhere (not Barty) that we do not know about. Gosh.. I hope it
> isn't Lupin. I am sure it is not. Also Snape is still friends with
> Malfoy, would he be if LV knew that he was the one who *left me
> forever*. He is not the coward. And how could he spy if LV knew he
> was not still one of his DE?
>


Valky:
Oh yeah, of course Tammy, I forgot to mention in my other post to
this thread, I love the Snape *was* there theory as much as I ever
did. OTOH I just can't get my head around it, it's spawned all kinds
of nasty ESE's, which it should do.

The best one, mostly because I can personally cope with it because I
don't care for these characters, is Ludo Bagman is the coward and
Karkaroff is the traitor...

For what ever reason whether its ESE Lupin denial or just because I
really believe it, I generally just go with Snape having been the
one that seemed to be a traitor.

|
|
|
|
|
|

Book Six is a time for answers. How are we doing with the questions?

Submit your _OWL_ essay to Row 97 today.

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/The_Prophecy_Orb

*   
*  *
|
|
|
|  _Signum Orbis_