In Defense of Snape (Potions Class Prediction)

vmonte vmonte at yahoo.com
Wed Jan 19 11:47:53 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 122365


Betsy wrote:
I don't see how Snape's behavior has weakened Harry. I don't even
see how it's weakened Neville. Both boys did quite well in the MoM
battle. I'm not sure what it is you feel Snape should do for them.

vmonte responds:
They weren't fighting with potions though were they.


vmonte again:

This is what I want to happen in book 6. The Owl results come back 
and someone unexpected will do wonderfully in their Potions Owl. And 
like Harry with his DADA classes, begins to teach the children this 
subject on the sly.

I would love for one of the students to be even better at Potions 
than Snape, as well as a wonderful teacher.

Oh won't Snape be mad! HEEEEE







More information about the HPforGrownups archive