Abusive Crouch!Moody (was: In Defense of Snape)

[horridporrid03]

No: HPFGUIDX 123165


>>Carol:
<snip>
>Compare Crouch!Moody, who turns Draco into a ferret and bounces him. 
Draco may have deserved it, but it must have hurt him physically as 
well as emotionally and that's child abuse in my book...< 
 
>>Alla:
<snip>
>Actually, when I started this post, I only wanted to comment on 
Crouch!Moody. I actually think that he did a remarkable job of 
controlling his temper. I don't think he was angry at all at this 
moment. I believe that the action was well thought out and very well 
executed. :)<

Betsy:
Alla, are you seriously condoning Crouch!Moody publically humiliating 
and physically assaulting Draco?  Does it matter if he did it out of 
anger or not? 

Betsy