Abusive Crouch!Moody (was: In Defense of Snape)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 123167


Alla:
> <snip>
Actually, when I started this post, I only wanted to comment on 
Crouch!Moody. I actually think that he did a remarkable job of 
controlling his temper. I don't think he was angry at all at this 
moment. I believe that the action was well thought out and very well 
executed. :)<
 
Betsy:
Alla, are you seriously condoning Crouch!Moody publically 
humiliating and physically assaulting Draco?  Does it matter if he 
did it out of anger or not? 


Alla:

Nope, I don't condone what he did to Draco at all, even though I WAS 
amused by the incident, but I most certainly don't condone it.

No matter how much I dislike Draco, he did not deserve it.

But you misunderstood me completely. My comment had nothing to do 
with Draco. Carol COMPARED Snape's ability to control his anger to 
crouch!Moody and I responded that IMO Crouch!Moody controlled his 
anger MUCH better than Snape does.

Just my opinion,

Alla