Incomprehensible comparison of Sirius and Aragorn

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 123363


Carol responds:
Forgive me, but unless you and I are reading different books, Sirius
was not seeking justice in PoA, he was seeking revenge, a whole
different concept. In his own words, he wanted to commit the murder 
he had been arrested for committing. It wouldn't bring James and Lily
back; it would cost him his own soul via a Dementor's mouth; it would
accomplish nothing except to still the maniacal desire to plunge a
twelve-inch knife into the heart of a rat the size of the knife 
blade.

Alla:

I am afraid we are reading different books then, Carol. :o) Because 
concept of justice to me includes bringing guilty party to just 
punishment.

Sure Sirius wanted revenge ( I cannot blame him at all), but he 
wanted revenge on someone who he knew FOR SURE was guilty, so I 'd 
say he was seeking justice too.

And for someone who was so bent up on revenge,a s you suggested, he 
agrees with Harry's suggestion to bring Peter to castle awfully 
fast, IMO.


Just my opinion,

Alla