[HPforGrownups] Re: Incomprehensible comparison of Sirius and Aragorn

[Juli]

No: HPFGUIDX 123373



Carol responds:
<huge snippage>
 
> I see no resemblance of any kind to Aragorn, who is
> violent only in
> battle against Orcs and never at any point desires
> to murder those who
> have betrayed him. Aragorn is a born captain, loved
> by many men (and
> two women), concerned not with his personal life but
> with his duty to
> the people of Middle Earth. Sirius cares only for
> himself and James,
> and to a lesser degree for Remus and pre-betrayal
> Peter. 

Juli now:
It's hard to explain why I think they are alike, call
it a gut feeling, sixth sense, intuition. There is
something that just makes me think they are alike, I
tried to explain it before but I guess I wasn't very
convincing. There's just something about them.

> Carol, who does see a Gollum/Kreacher resemblance
> and we doesn't like
> it at all, no, precious, we doesn't

Juli:
it's creepy, they are both creepy. Maybe towards the
end Kreacher will serve the WW just like Gollum
*saved* middle earth. But still I can't see redemption
for him, he willingly sent Harry to the MoM which he
knew was just to hurt him. He betrayed his master...
Anyways, I agree Carol I don't like that resemblance,
it makes me nervous, ichy, it makes me wonder if we
still haven't seem the worst of Kreacher.

Juli


		
__________________________________ 
Do you Yahoo!? 
Yahoo! Mail - 250MB free storage. Do more. Manage less. 
http://info.mail.yahoo.com/mail_250