James, a paragon of virtue? Was: Why Do You Like Sirius?

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 123412


Nora:
But Snape is currently the sympathetic one, in terms of the 
James/Snape conflict--and if we find out why he converted, we should 
also find out the deep dirt.<
 
Betsy:
Not per Harry, and also not per some folks on this list. 

Alla:

Definitely per Harry Snape does come sympathetic in that scene, 
because Harry does not feel sorry for James , he feels sorry for 
Snape.


Betsy: (Denial she do run deep.) 

Alla: I am confused about this part of your statement.

 
Betsy:
And I do agree that we will learn about Snape as a 
Death Eater, and that it won't be pretty.  Usually a crisis of 
conscience occurs when hitting rock bottom.

Alla:

Yes, this part I agree with.


JMO,

Alla