WW Cultural bias re clothes and cupboard?

finwitch finwitch at yahoo.com
Mon Jan 31 11:39:09 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 123549



> Arynn replies,
> It's not that the "room" had no windows, it's that the "room" was so
small. It's not even big enough for Harry to stand upright in. I don't
know how it is in other countries, but in America, if people keep
their animals in conditions like that, they loose thier animals. 
>  
> I know wizards can magically expand small spaces, but as Harry is
underaged, he would get in trouble for that. My question is why didn't
Dumbledore do it? 

Finwitch:

First off, since the first Hogwarts letter (which Harry didn't get to
read) arrived, Harry was moved into a larger bedroom. AND, he was SO
underage he wasn't even going to Hogwarts yet, he didn't even have a
wand... and we never saw any warning owls about any magic Harry did
until after he'd been a year at Hogwarts. (apparently Hermione didn't
get any when she was practicing her spells?)

But well... as much as Harry liked to have the room - he would prefer
*the letter*, even if it meant he still had to stay in the cupboard. I
don't think the size is the issue. No. It's the fact they *locked* it,
and Harry had to trick himself out for food in order to survive...

Finwitch







More information about the HPforGrownups archive