Peter, Sirius, or Lupin: who was the spy again?

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 131799

> > Alla:
> > 
> > Erm.. he was not looking for Harry with a knife, he cut Fat Lady
> > with a knife, while looking for Peter and yes, it is an
> > understandable  behaviour of someone who suffered twelve years
> > because of certain person and was willing to find such person by 
any
> > means.
> 
>    Kathy:
>    Maybe, but you sure give him more leeway than poor, old, down-
trodden 
> Snape.


Alla:

You mean I think that someone who spent twelve years in prison under 
horrible  conditions with Dementors sucking away every happy thought 
from him has more reason to be irrational ( right after he escaped 
if I may) than someone who spent those twelve years in the safety of 
Hogwarts, under protection of Dumbledore?

Absolutely, I do think so.


>    Kathy:
>    But you are ignoring my point.  Who else besides Sirius is 
portrayed
>    as the same kind of dangerous, violent, competant, veteran?  
JKR made
>    him that way for a reason or he would look more like Lupin.

Alla:

Now I don't understand. Are you saying Sirius is more likely to be a 
Voldemort spy than Snape? Erm... I actually never accused Snape of 
being Voldie spy now. Well, no scratch that - I had my doubts when 
Harry felt worse after Occlumency, but that was just a tiny doubt, 
honestly. :-)

So, if you think that Snape can be Voldie spy now, please 
ellaborate :-)

 

> > Alla earlier:
> > 
> > I think there is such thing as instant affection for each other.
> 
>    Kathy:
> 
>       I've never suffered from it, nor would I if on one page the 
person 
> was choking me, and dragging my best friend around, and a few 
pages 
> later, suggesting that I live with him.  I don't think you would 
either.


Alla:

Let me refer you to Guinger excellent reply 131794.

>    Kathy:
<SNIP>
He didn't die for Harry, he was dying of boredom and couldn't wait 
> to get a little action. He had no common sense at all.


Alla:

You mean the fact that Harry was in DoM had nothing to do with 
Sirius going there? 

I'd like to finish on agree to disagree note.


JMO,

Alla.