OOTP observations - Molly/Molly's worst moment in the books?
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Thu Jul 14 01:34:39 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 132692
Phoenixgod:
<SNIP>
> So she is right to bully her husband? She was right to forget
about
> the Twins when she was happy that Ron had become a prefect? so she
> was right to try and crush the dreams of the twins when they don't
> fit into her version of what they should do? Molly has the right
to
> raise her kids they way she wants but she goes out of her way to
> belittle ideas and dreams they have that are not hers.
Alla:
You know what I just realised? If I were to nominate Molly's worst
moment in the books, I would not pick her believing Rita Skeeter's
lies about Harry and Hermione, I would not pick her running her
mouth at Sirius ( although I definitely wanted to slap her many
times over that one) No, my number one choice would be her
forgetting about twins.
I mean everything else I could explain by her understanding of love,
jealousy of Sirius, etc. I cannot justify , but at least I can
explain those moments.
Her forgetting about the fact she has two more sons, I find close
to unforgivable.
I even can understand her yelling at twins about joke shop. She was
probably very concerned that they won't have a steady job after
graduation, but forgetting about them, no I cannot understand that.
I guess there is an explanation for that, but I just don't see any.
Would welcome one.
Now, having said all that, I DO like Molly. If for nothing else, for
the wonderful children she brought up, so she must have been doing a
lot of things right. :-)
Just my opinion,
Alla.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive