How did Fawkes' feathers end up in LV and HP's wands?
davenclaw
daveshardell at yahoo.com
Fri Jul 15 13:46:34 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 132867
I was thinking this morning about the fact that Fawkes provided the
feathers for both LV and HP's wands, and I began to wonder how this
came about. At first it seemed like a trivial matter but I soon
realized that this has the potential for much more.
Now, according to JKR's answer to the FAQ poll question,
Dumbledore's patronus is the Phoenix. I think we have to conclude
that Dumbledore came to possess Fawkes before he provided the
feathers for the wands. I doubt that Ollivander first had access to
Fawkes and then said "Hey Dumbledore, why don't you take this bird,
no one seems to be matching up with the wands I made from his
feathers." Possible, but doubtful.
So let's say that DD gave Ollivander two feathers and asked him to
make wands. Did he know that the people who had good results with
those wands would be special? Did he ask Ollivander to let him know
whenever anyone matched one of those wands? Why did he use two
different types of wood? Did Prof DD know that young Tom Riddle was
in possession of a wand made from his phoenix? Or did he not even
have Fawkes at that time (which, as I said above, I doubt)? What
does it mean that for some 50 years the other wand sat in
Ollivander's shop collecting dust? Does LV know that his wand is
made from DD's phoenix? Does this give DD some sort of leverage
over LV that makes him the one wizard who LV fears?
Whew. Catching my breath. I hope this is explored in HBP!
- davenclaw, who stupidly pre-ordered the book from Amazon and whose
inconsiderate friend scheduled his post-wedding party for Saturday,
meaning that he won't see the book till late Saturday night, almost
24 hours after everyone else...
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive