If Snape is good, how will he now help the Order? (more)
templar1112002
templar1112002 at yahoo.com
Tue Jul 19 21:58:41 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 133199
Julie / fourjays22 wrote:
> Assuming that Snape indeed was acting on DD's order to AK him, and
> that
> he is still on the side of the Order, how will he help the Order?
It
> seemed from the end of HBP that no one from the Order is likely to
> trust Snape now that DD is dead at Snape's hand.
>
> I'm wondering how he (Snape) might work his double-agent role now,
> because it seems like his primary assistance to the Order was
sending
> back information about the DEs. Is there another member of the
Order
> (again assuming Snape is on the Order's side) who might know as
much
> about Snape as DD and is still willing to trust him? Could it be
the
> member of the Order we are to be introduced to more completely in
Book
> 7 (that JKR
> has
> referenced in her interviews?) Maybe Aberforth?
>
> Curious as how all of you think this might play out!
>
**Marcela: In my message 132916, I theorized about this. This is
the part referring to your question here.
[snip of post 132916]
8. Dumbledore made Harry promise him to follow his orders/wishes
even if they didn't make sense to Harry. (Cave chapter? or previous
one?)
I have reason to suspect that Dumbledore had asked the same from
Snape: in the event that Draco were about to kill him, Snape should
do it. A dead Snape would be worthless to the cause, :)
That way, Snape'd have proven beyond any doubt that he was loyal to
Voldie. But. I get the feeling that Dumbledore asked Snape to help
Harry/Order after his death. Maybe another Unbreakable Vow? But
who'd have been the 'third' party? New character in HP7? Or one of
those Order members that Jo mentioned in her last interview, that
we've heard of but don't know them well yet?
"If" Snape was loyal to Dumbledore, this new or semi-new character
will be very important in HP7, because so far the Order believed
that Snape had betrayed them. This way, when this Order member
confesses that Snape is truly loyal to them, then things would not
look that grim for Harry/Order.
I suspect of this because Snape had tons of opportunities to hex
Harry at the end, he could have stupefied him and taken him to
Voldie. But Snape didn't. He not only "told" Harry what he needed to
do: close his mind and learn silent casting of spells, but he also
convinced the other DE's to leave Harry.
[end snip]
So, I'd think Aberforth is a good candidate. Curiously, there is a
parallelism with Bella and Cissy being sisters in the Unbreakable
Vow with Snape...and Albus and Aberforth are brothers...
Marcela
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive