Valky's confession; The Snape Hater Club

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 133565


John:

> > DD pleaded with Snape, and yet he was cold blooded enough to kill 
> > him like a dog in the dirt. For this, Snape is, in my book, 
worthy 
> > of death at the hands of Harry.

Alexa:
<SNIP> 
> And what of Harry, himself? What of this young man who forced cup 
> after cup of poison down the throat of a trembling, terrified, 
> pleading old man who was in physical and emotional anguish, on his 
> knees, on his back, groveling in the dirt on the floor a cave?
> 
> What is he worthy of?


Alla:

The difference between Snape and Harry situation is that we KNOW that 
Dumbledore ordered Harry to force feed him the potion. We don't KNOW 
whether Dumbledore ordered Snape to kill him, it is just a theory.



For now, I  am very much doubting that Dumbledore could order anyone 
to do the killing.


Another big difference is that Harry is doing his best to save 
Dumbledore, contrary to Snape to kills him with hatred on his face.

So, what is Harry worth of in my mind ? That would be deepest sympathy


I am also doubting "Snape as a deep mole theory" for the simple 
reason that there is nobody whom Snape could give his reports to, 
since ( finally) all Order of Phoenix is on the same page as Harry is 
as to Snape.


Just me of course,

Alla.