OWLs - still don't add up
rolshan2000
rolshan2000 at yahoo.com
Wed Jul 20 18:53:46 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 133572
I appreciate how minor this is in light of the more earthshaking
events and revelations in HBP (the best book yet, by the way, in my
view; and I for one think the ships were beautifully done and very
consistent with the foreshadowing in the prior books), but I still
can't get Hermione's OWLs to add up.
We are told she got 11 OWLs, but she was only taking 10 classes - no?
She was taking the same ones as Harry and Ron, as confirmed by their
OWL test report, which were 9, minus Divination, makes 8, plus
Ancient Runes and Arithmancy which makes 10. So how could she get 11
OWLS? The theory that some subjects resulted in more than one OWL
seems shot. I suppose it is possible Hermione took an OWL exam in a
subject she was not taking at school (for example, she could
obviously get an O OWL in Muggle Studies without taking the Hogwarts
course) but it seems odd this would not have been mentioned!
Further, even allowing Hermione her 11 OWLs, we still don't know how
the legendary students of the past (Bill Weasley, that boy who was
selling study aids in OOP, etc.) ever managed 12 OWLs, without use of
Time Turners.
Anyone?
Rolshan
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive