RAB, The Cave, and the Horcrux

[Marisa Crosset]

No: HPFGUIDX 133852

Amy wrote:
<snip>
> Dumbledore and Harry had trouble both fitting into the boat.  DD said 
> it had something to do with the fact that LV wouldn't be worried about 
> the number of people, but the power of the magic involved.  One 
> powerful wizard would be ok, but two obviously wouldn't work.  
> So . . .  If it was indeed Regulus, could it be that Kreacher was the 
> other "person" helping him obtain the locket?!?  Am I on to something, 
> please oh please?!
> 

Hi Amy!

I heard this theory also mentioned on mugglenet and I really, 
really think you are on to something. Not only is it an exciting 
possibility, but also makes tremendous sense from a writer's 
standpoint. This is how JKR can explain Harry finding out exactly 
what happened when RAB went after the Horcrux! Also, we know 
that house elves have powerful magic, but LV would 
underestimate them as he underestimates underage wizards.

Marisa