WHEN PAM HAS BOTOX/GOODBYE WRINKLES, part 2 (LONG)

jlnbtr jlnbtr at yahoo.com
Fri Jul 22 03:35:46 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 134028

TortieKitten wrote:
...edited...
 
Lowering her voice, TortieKitten continued. "I know that many people 
would probably scream at me for this repeated theory. But mine is 
different. My belief is that Harry was not *intended* to be a 
Horcrux. Instead, Voldemort's soul had been split when he killed 
Lily and James, and when he attempted to kill Harry, part of his 
soul entered Harry without either of them noticing." 

Juli: But if Harry is the sixth Horcrux, then in order for Voldemort 
to be truly vanquished, then Harry must die before him. And if 
harry's dead who's supposed to kill LV? Or is there any other way to 
destroy an Horcrux? We know the Horcrux!Diary was killed when Harry 
stabbed the diary with a basilik's teeth, then Dumbledore cracked 
the Marvolo Ring and destroyed the Horcrux. So as I see it, if Harry 
is indeed an Horcrux, then he must be killed before Voldemort, which 
I doubt could happen.

> "Well, I don't think Snape is ESE!,"  "I believe, as many do, that 
Snape was looking out for number one," TortieKitten said, "and that 
when faced with the decision to break his Vow or to break 
Dumbledore's trust, he took the one that was less likely to kill 
him, and moved on." She gave Kaylee another squirt gun  to read.

Juli: So according to you, even if Snape isn't evil, he's a 
murderer? He'd rather save his ass, than save the one person who's 
trust him all along? This seems incredibly selfish to me, and I 
don't really see Snape as selfish, an arrogant bastard, yes, but not 
selfish. He must have known that if he killed Dumbledore, half the 
wizard world would come for him, so he'd be as good as dead anyway. 
I believe Snape murdered DD because he was ordered to do so, 
Dumbledore begged him to end his life (and in the meantime save 
Draco's). Of course I could be completly wrong.

Juli - Wellcome TortieKitten, I hope you enjoy yourself. And BTW, 
your anagram made me laugh, a lot.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive