SOOOOOO many questions!

[Schumar1999]

No: HPFGUIDX 134228

Aggie: <snip> 
Also, (I KNOW Snape's been done to death but I can't fathom this bit 
> out AT ALL)WHY oh WHY did Snape attack Flitwick???  I'm of the "Snape's 
> ultimately on the side of good" camp but this is the one piece of the 
> jigsaw that just does not fit!!  Does this mean that he IS just a bad 
> guy and that's it or that Flitwick's a bad guy, or Maybe Flitwick knew 
> of the plan and was going to try and stop Snape. I'm just soooo 
> confused! 


Schumar: 
I believe that, and I know I've said that before, Snape "attacked" Flitwick in order to 
carry out his mission for Dumbledore. His attack was just a mere stunning, nothing 
unforgiveable or serious, where I believe a truly evil Snape would have killed Flitwick and the 
girls... 'cause obviously he wouldn't have cared about keeping his job and protecting any of 
the good people. It seems to me that Snape stunned Flitwick in much the same way 
Dumbledore stunned Harry... to keep him from interfering with what Must be done. 

Marianne S.