Snape/Dumbledore argument

snipsnapsnurr snipsnapsnurr at yahoo.com
Sat Jul 23 00:42:58 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 134294

I'm trying to figure out what Hagrid overheard Snape and 
Dumbledore arguing about. What did Snape want to stop doing? I can 
only think of a few things that he is doing and none of them really 
fit.

1. He is spying for the Order. If he wanted to stop doing that, why 
would he discuss it with Dumbledore? Wouldn't he just stop?

2. He is teaching DADA. Why would he want to stop doing that? That 
has been his ambition throughout the whole series.

3. He is investigating the Slytherins to see if any of them were 
involved with the cursed necklace. Again, if he wanted to stop doing 
that, wouldn't he just stop? If Dumbledore asked him how the 
investigation was going, he would just say he hadn't come up with 
anything.

4. He is trying to help Draco accomplish his task. But Draco won't 
let him. So he can't do that anyway.


So maybe he is involved in some other project and we haven't been 
told about it. Maybe something along the lines of. . . I don't 
know. . . hunting for Voldemort's horcruxes and destroying them.


snipsnapsnurr










More information about the HPforGrownups archive