Rumors that Harry was a Dark Wizard
Kristen
hexicon at yahoo.com
Sat Jul 23 17:04:04 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 134494
I have questions about the rumors that Harry was a Dark wizard. I
don't recall seeing much discussion of this yet (but I haven't been
able to keep up with posts and the search function isn't working
well, so bear with me).
In HBP Chapter 2, "Spinner's End," Snape tells Bellatrix and Narcissa
that "when Potter first arrived at Hogwarts there were still many
stories circulating about him, rumors that he himself was a great
Dark Wizard, which was how he had survived the Dark Lord's attack.
Indeed, many of the Dark Lord's followers thought Potter might be a
standard around which we could rally once more."
To me, this assertion about the Death Eaters' beliefs was a
surprise. I went back through the books thinking of evidence that
might back this statement. I'm guessing that Snape isn't simply
making this up to throw off the two sisters, because his reference to
the belief of "many of the Dark Lord's followers" would be fairly
easy for Bellatrix to verify.
Is this the reason for Snape's questioning of Harry at the first
Potions class (SS ch 8)? (Powdered root of asphodel to infusion of
wormwood, where to find a bezoar, monkshood/wolfsbane.) Is he trying
to suss out Harry's familiarity with the Dark Arts? (The HPB, of
course, adds additional signficance to the bezoar.)
I can't seem to find evidence of any other professors testing Harry
in this way . . . but what about Ollivander's ambiguous "great
things" statement (SS ch 5)?
Draco is reasonably friendly to Harry in Madam Malkin's, before he
knows who Harry is(SS ch 5), but after a brief attempt to suck up
with the "wrong sort" statement in the train, he quickly takes
offense and lobs the "go the same way as your parents" comment(SS ch
6). If the Malfoys suspected Harry could be the next Voldemort, it
seems like Draco would have been more persistent in trying to
establish good relations.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive