What would convince Harry/canned memories

[Cathy Drolet]

No: HPFGUIDX 134594

Amanda wrote:
"PUTTING A MEMORY IN THE PENSIEVE TAKES IT OUT OF YOUR HEAD" and "The 
obvious corollary I draw is: if it's not in your head, *you don't 
know
it anymore.*"

snapeo'phile
"First let me say, that that is a BRILLIANT theory, really excellent 
and well thought out.

But what occured to me is, if you no longer have the memory, how could 
you remember to look for it later? Because, you wouldn't know what you 
were looking for when you needed it later, would you?


It would have to still be there...must still be there in fact... or Slughorn could not have given the correct memory to Harry.  I don't believe for a moment that DD gave his bottled memory back to Slughorn...he's had that one a long time, not just since Slug's been in the castle.  JMO.

CathyD
DuffyPoo - I know, I know, I'm over my limit.


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]