What would convince Harry/canned memories

[Shannon]

No: HPFGUIDX 134703

> Isn't it possible that you would have memories of that initial 
memory?  All
> memories are like thread posts; there may be a thread of that memory 
that is
> remembered, though the complete memory would be in the original 
strand of
> memory.
> Craig

Momy424 here:

If your memories were lost totally when you put them in a pensive like 
I had originally thought, then how would Slughorn pull out the correct 
memory for Harry and give it to him if he had already given (albeit 
edited) to DD already?

I have to think that you keep the memory in your head, but maybe as you 
see it, but when it goes into the pensive it shows that actual memory 
as it happened and not with just your own "spin" on it.