Harry's Scar / Snape switched the locket ,/and other theories

[jlnbtr]

No: HPFGUIDX 134927

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Auria" <rytal at y...> wrote:
...edited...

> I have two questions which I'd like other people's comments on:
> 
> 1. In HBP how come Harry's scar is no longer hurting him?  

Juli: when Dumbledore picks Harry up at Privet Drive, and just when 
they arrive at the Burrow, Dumbledore asks Harry if his scar's been 
hurting, Harry answers No, and he thinks it's weird, Dumbledore says 
it's because Voldemort is using occlumency against Harry.
 
> 2. When Harry retrieves the locket from Dumbledore's pocket after 
he 
> has been killed by Snape, Harry notices the locket is smaller than 
> the one he remembered seeing in the Pensieve right? Well, is it 
> possible that DD and Harry DID retrieve the real horcrux locket 
but 
> that it was switched by Snape and Malfoy from DD's body at the 
foot 
> of the tower just before Harry caught up with them?  If so then 
this 
> would mean Snape IS a triple agent and has taken the real horcrux 
to 
> destroy it.
> Could this be possible?  

Juli: I don't think so, Dumbledore, seemed to know the Horcrux was a 
fake from the moment he took it, I guess that he just didn't want 
Harry to know, how horrible would he feel knowing that he made 
Dumbledore drink that poison for nothing? I think DD was going to 
tell him eventually. But of course, I could be completely wrong, and 
Snape changed the locket, the question is When? Was Snape ever alone 
with Dumbledore? As I remember he wasn't.


Juli