Slughorn impersonating DD? Was: Re: Harry's Scar / Snape switched the locket ,/and other theories

[Auria]

No: HPFGUIDX 135048

> Auria:
> > I'm also enjoying the theory I read on some posts that DD's 'Oho!' 
in
> > the cave means it is really Slughorn.
> Sarah:
> But Slughorn is seen at both the meeting called by McGonagall, and at
> the funeral.  Unless Dumbledore is now impersonating Slughorn?



Yep, thats exactly what I was thinking - could it be that Slughorn 
sacrificed himself in swopping appearances with Dumbledore?  I was 
really keen on this theory except that last night I read in an 
interview with JK Rowling that said after she killed off Sirius in OoP 
she was tearful but that at the end of writing HBP she was really upset 
about the ending.  So that kind of indicates that DD's death may well 
be for real I'm afraid.
Auria