Clues Convergent Redux -- Snape is a nice wizard because .....

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 134929

Zgirnius wrote:
<SNIP>
> Speaking of the UV...why do you think Snape took it in HBP? I 
can't 
> find a reason for a loyal DE *or* super-evil-out-for-himself Snape 
to 
> do this.


Alla:

I actually can say the opposite. I think that if Snape was at that 
moment at the side of good, he would NOT have taken UV in the first 
place.

I mean, Bella was against Narcissa divulging her secrets to Snape in 
the first place, right?

All that Snape needed to say, was to tell her that as a loyal
follower 
of Dark Lord, Narcissa should keep her secrets and /or her son's 
secrets in the first place and not tell them to anybody, even to him.

I mean it is easy to say afterwards - Snape did not have a choice 
but 
to kill Dumbledore because he took a Vow.

My question is why Snape took a  Vow in the first place, especially
if 
he indeed knew what Draco's task is.

It was incredibly reckless to say the least, IMO.




> 
> --zgirnius, Who thinks that, anyway, Snape is provably ESI (Ever 
So 
> Interesting)


Alla:

THAT we absolutely agree on.

I find him MUCH more interesting after HBP.



JMO,

Alla.