Does Dung have the Horcrux? was Harry's not a Horcrux was In Essence Divided

Sharon azriona at juno.com
Tue Jul 26 11:37:07 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 134991

Karen said:
So, unless there was a third party there who 
> did know the significance, which is debatable as I don't think even 
> Snape or other Death Eaters knew about them then, if now then one of 
> the Horcruxes is probably still in the ruins of Godrick's Hollow.


But wouldn't it have been unused, since as Harry didn't die, Voldy 
didn't make the horcrux, and the object then was either stored in some 
DE's home, or left in Godric's Hollow?  (And if it was the latter, how 
much you want to bet Mundungus Fletcher sold it on the black market?)

Actually...speaking of "Black" markets....you don't suppose one of 
those things that Dung was stealing from Grimmauld Place could have 
been the horcrux, do you?  Not a clue how it would have gotten there, 
but there has to be a reason why what Dung was sealing was important, 
else JKR wouldn't have included the scene.

--azriona







More information about the HPforGrownups archive