Does Dung have the Horcrux? was Harry's not a Horcrux was In Essence Divided

electrawman2 electrawman2 at yahoo.com
Tue Jul 26 20:43:00 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 135086

azriona wrote:
> Actually...speaking of "Black" markets....you don't suppose one 
> of those things that Dung was stealing from Grimmauld Place could 
> have been the horcrux, do you?  Not a clue how it would have 
> gotten there, but there has to be a reason why what Dung was 
> stealing was important, else JKR wouldn't have included the scene.


Yes, exactly!  What was the point of the scene if it doesn't play 
out later?

I thought perhaps that the cup (which has now been mentioned twice) 
might actually be the Hufflepuff cup in disguise, but it's doubtful 
that both the locket *and* the cup would end up in 12 GP, 
so....*shrug*

"electrawman2"







More information about the HPforGrownups archive