It's About Motive

[elizabeththedragonslayer]

No: HPFGUIDX 135065

Julie <drjuliehoward at y...> wrote:
> I thought we could start a list of observations that we have 
> made for which there is no canon evidence as yet for motive. 
> Anyone care to join? 
> 
> 1. Why did Snape kill DD?
> 2. Why did DD trust Snape?
> 3. Why did LV kill James but said that Lily did not have to die?
> 4. Why did DD say to Petunia, "Remember my last"?

Best quesses:

1.  Because it is part of the master plan that he and DD devised
which only he and DD know the details of.  

2.  Snake went to DD for some emotionally charged reason and DD 
extracted a wizard's promise from him.

3.  Clueless

4.  I think JKR answered this already.  I'm wondering what he's 
holding her in check with?

"elizabeththedragonslayer"