Am I the only one...

a_fabrefr Fabre.a at caramail.com
Tue Jul 26 20:37:26 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 135073


> Milz wrote:
> "Never said Hermione lacks intelligence. I've stated that she's 
not on
> the same plane of intellect as HBP or Fred and George."
<SNIP>


I've nothing against the Twin and like them, but I can't figure how 
you can say they are such genius. All we know is that they create 
some funny artefacts. For me to be at pair with Newton or Einstein 
they should investigate the nature of magic or create a news way to 
understand the word. To date they just seems to be good ingenier. By 
the way I think the magic world lack the ability to try to push and 
study the boundary of knowledge, I know it's necessary for the plot 
but they seems to copy the muggle (railways, car, telescope) more 
than create.
Hermione with he muggle backgroud could probably be more capable to 
have a critic eyes on the accepted theorie in the magic world.
Alexandre








More information about the HPforGrownups archive