Sirius and Prank again? Fools Rush in ...

[M.Clifford]

No: HPFGUIDX 129962


> Valky:
> <SNIP>
> Sirius does not think Sevvie was blameless, and apparently neither 
> did Dumbledore.
> 
> 
>  Alla:
> 
> I don't know for sure what Dumbledore thinks of course, but I 
> believe that what you are saying IS a possibility, because I
> always thought that " My memory is as good as ever" to be opened 
> to very wide interpretations.
> 
> 
> > Valky:
> > I based that on the fact that Sirius was not given a satisfactory
> > punishment according to Snape. So it is fairly clear that 
> > Dumbledore doesn't agree with Snape about the level of  
> > responsibility each child had for the whole thing. 
> >
> > ...edited...
> > 

> 
> bboyminn:
> 
> OK, so how was Sirius punished? Do you know? Of course you don't and
> that is the whole point. You don't know so you can say with 
> certainty whether the punishment was fair or not. 
> 

Valky:
Huh? :s
Read again, it says that the punishment/discipline was not
satisfactory **according to Snape**. Not me! 

Steve:
> And since when does Snape get to decide what punishments are handed
> out by the headmaster? Are you implying that 16 year old Snape knows
> better and is more objective than the 130 year old headmaster of the
> school? I think not.

Valky:
Not even nearly Steve, read again. I said that Dumbledore doesn't
agree with Snape. So since DD is a fair person, theres HEAPS of reason
to believe that Snape is just carrying on about it, hence Sirius
wasn't trying to murder anyone.

Hey BTW I am graduating my opinion to agree with Eric Oppens, Really
good post Eric!




Steve:
>  Snape is still holding a grudge in the matter, absolving
> himself and placing full blame on Sirius,
> 

Valky:
Thats exactly what I said.

Steve: 
> You are certainly free to speculate that Sirius tried to kill/murder
> Snape, but there is no evidence of that fact.


Valky:
Hey! I was the one who said "tried" was too strong a word. 
I'm with Eric, and if I remember correctly, some months ago I posted a
scenario that was like your reverse psychology scenario. I am not
trying to claim first dibs but seriously Steve... *puts hands up*....
I am innocent see for yourself.