"Some won't like it".

madorganization alishak at spu.edu
Fri Jun 3 16:42:50 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 130006

Alisha:
> > Yes, he has faced more than Ron or Hermione. Yes, Voldemort 
> > is trying to kill him. These things are true and valid,
> > but since when do either of them make him more entitled to
> > information? 

Eggplant: 
> To answer your question I'd say since human beings developed a 
> basic sense of justice. More than any other person on the planet 
> Harry has earned the right to know what's going on and what is 
> trying to kill him and why. Harry has every right to be angry when 
> this is denied him, especially when it caused the death of his 
> Godfather. When Harry was wrecking Dumbledore's office I was 
> cheering, I just wish he'd taked a swing at him.


Alisha:
I really think you're missing the point of my whole post.  The point 
is that in the scene I was referring to, Harry doesn't know these 
things yet.  He doesn't know that it will lead to the death of his 
godfather (which really, is just a result of Harry not listening when people /do/ tell him things).  I was happy when he was upset in DD's office as well.  It was about time he got upset.  It's not the anger of Harry that bothers me.  It's his superior attitude towards those who he knows care about him.

Alisha - who thinks Harry's attitude problem in OotP is nothing 
compared to Sirius's









More information about the HPforGrownups archive