"Some won't like it".

eggplant107 eggplant107 at hotmail.com
Sat Jun 4 16:42:10 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 130041

"madorganization" <alishak at s...> wrote:


> in the scene I was referring to, 
> Harry doesn't know these things yet.

I don't know the scene you're referring to but from page 1 Harry knew
he had done more than any wizard in living memory, if he was honest
with himself he must have known that. And from page 1 he knew he was
being treated like dirt and he figured he didn't deserve that and it
made him angry. It would make me angry too.

> He doesn't know that it will lead to the 
> death of his godfather (which really, is
> just a result of Harry not listening when
> people /do/ tell him things

You are the one not listening, you are not listening to Dumbledore, he
said it was almost entirely his fault alone and I think he was quite
correct. And Dumbledore told him very little, most of the time it was
Snape saying Dumbledore said this or that; and as the book progressed
Harry had less and less reason to trust in Dumbledore's judgment and
even less reason to trust Snape. 

> It's not the anger of Harry that bothers
> me. It's his superior attitude towards 
> those who he knows care about him.

But Harry doesn't act superior, he just had the thought that he has
done more than they, AND HE HAS.

Eggplant  
 
 









More information about the HPforGrownups archive