Harry's entitlement - Long!(was Re: "Some won't like it".)
festuco
vuurdame at xs4all.nl
Sat Jun 4 07:46:25 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 130020
> No it wasn't. They kew exactly what Voldemort was after and how he
> was going to try and get it. thats why they weren't telling him
> anything. All Snape told him was that Voldemort could get into his
> head and use his emotions. Not the why of the situation. Why would
> Voldemort spend his time picking through Harry's head? why would he
> try to make Harry do anything? Harry doesn't have any knowledge,
> power and influnce for Voldemort go after (as far as Harry knew),
> what could he possibly want that was locked in Harry's head?
Now I don't agree. If a supposedly smart 15 year old cannot understand
why it is a bad thing the main enemy has a direct connection to his
mind, he deserves to be kept in the dark. This level of stupidity is
frankly downright dangerous. Besides if someone cannot understand this
very simple fact, what else do they need to have spelled out for them
which is so very, very obvious? If Harry were five, yes, telling why
would have been necessary. But he is 15!
I agree that DD should have told more. But here it was Harry who was
entirely to blame for his unwillingness to understand. I don't believe
that LV's influence reaches much beyond the dreams.
Gerry
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive