"Some won't like it".

[festuco]

No: HPFGUIDX 130053

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "eggplant107" <eggplant107 at h...>
wrote:

> You are the one not listening, you are not listening to Dumbledore, he
> said it was almost entirely his fault alone and I think he was quite
> correct. And Dumbledore told him very little, most of the time it was
> Snape saying Dumbledore said this or that; and as the book progressed
> Harry had less and less reason to trust in Dumbledore's judgment and
> even less reason to trust Snape. 

Gerry

I don't agree. Dubledore made mistakes, yes. But that does not mean
Harry is blameless here. If he had used his brains, if he had paid
attention to his occlumency lessons, if he had used the two-way
mirror, if he had remembered Snape was a member of the order, than
things would have been different. 
> 
> > It's not the anger of Harry that bothers
> > me. It's his superior attitude towards 
> > those who he knows care about him.
> 
> But Harry doesn't act superior, he just had the thought that he has
> done more than they, AND HE HAS.

Gerry

And how do we know? Harry was not even alive for the largest part of
LV's reign of terror. DD has founded a society to actively oppose him,
he has been fighting him even now. He saved Harry's life two times, in
book 1 and in book 5. Both times Harry managed to get into trouble
with LV on his own and without any real need. Harry does not have clue
what other people have done, and thus we have none either. 

Gerry