SHIP Re: Sirius and Remus

firebird vloe at dallasnews.com
Fri Jun 24 04:05:45 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 131338

>Lissa:
>
>I think James and Sirius were completely platonic.
>
>
Firebird now:

This whole discussion poses the interesting quesiton: Does gaydar, to 
the degree that any of us has it, operate within a literary context? 
Oddly, I'd never considered the Sirius/Remus ship possibility. And my 
gut reaction is, "nope." But Sirius and James, now that's entirely a 
different matter. Even with James' attempts to catch Lily's eye, it 
seems to me that his interactions with Sirius in OoP (as remembered by 
Snape, at least) pretty much ooze sexual tension.

I'm not saying that was JKR's intention, or that they were actually 
lovers -- or that, even if they were, it has any bearing on Harry's 
journey. Just an observation that hadn't quite jelled for me before 
this thread. 

firebird 

 






More information about the HPforGrownups archive