Prophecies Always Come True?

[Tonks]

No: HPFGUIDX 131361

> 
> Apart from the TT episode, my other evidence I have for thinking that 
prophecies must come true is that Dumbledore says that Lord Voldemort 
 was not trying to 'thwart' the prophecy when he went to kill Harry; 
> instead he thought he was fulfiling its terms. In fact, he *did* 
> fulfil its terms, but not in the way he was expecting. and so I 
> conclude that the real magic of the prophecy is the way it is worded 
> so it shapes events in just the right way to make itself come about, 
> but without giving the whole plot away. 

Tonks:

Hummmm. Is it possible that the battle in the MoM was TT and the first 
time someone else went throught the veil. Sirius and DD come back to 
send Sirius instead of _______?? Because someone has to die and you 
can't change that, but you can change *who*??  I only have this 
question because you say that LV was there to fulfill the prophecy, not 
just see it.

Oh, it is just all too confusing for me.

Tonks_op