No: HPFGUIDX 125450 In GoF book we only saw some of Riddle's Bone dust, but I always felt it would have been more powerful if a ghastly white grinning skull with patches of dried blackened skin still clinging to it came out of the grave and plopped into the caldron with a sickening slash. I suppose Rowling felt that would have been a little too powerful. Eggplant