HBP / Dumbledore as HBP?

Valy valy1x2 at hotmail.com
Wed Mar 9 20:16:17 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 125819


Doddie:
<snip> anyone out there wondering or making new speculations about
> who the HBP is?  I'm beginning to wonder if it is Dumbledore...</snip>

Valy replies:
I'm beginning too, despite my thoughts are still set on Snape being the HBP.
Too much hints in my opinion, unless JKR is being evil and leading us on a
false way.
By seeing the covers, she's making us choose between DD and Snape...

<snip> I believe someone (perhaps Malfoy) made the comment that he
> was the champion of "mudbloods"...

Valy replies:
Nope, that's Voldemort who made this statement. :)

Jina said:
>This would make sense....if only JK said that he wasn't. I at first
>thought that it was DD too, but JK said he isn't (and neither is
>Harry).

Valy replies:
Really? I didn't know she ALSO said this.
I only remember "Neither Harry or Voldy"
I know she also said Hagrid wasn't (which is logical, he's half-breed, 
not half-blood)
And neither Ron, Draco, and any Malfoy.
But I really didn't know about Dumbledore.
Where did she say this? I'm a curious nature needing confirmations, but 
don't worry, I don't doubt your statements. I'm just wanting to see it... 
lol.  But JKR stated we will be very stunned at the discovery of the HBP.

Mmmh... I'm going to post a (spoilers heavy) theory about Snape being the
HBP.
See it coming!

Valy.








More information about the HPforGrownups archive