HBP - Dumbledore, Snape, Gryffindor?

fritts57 fritts57 at aol.com
Thu Mar 10 20:21:56 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 125881


> Doddie:
> <snip> anyone out there wondering or making new speculations about
> > who the HBP is?  I'm beginning to wonder if it is Dumbledore...
> 
> Valy replies:
> I'm beginning too, despite my thoughts are still set on Snape being 
> the HBP. Too much hints in my opinion, unless JKR is being evil and
> leading us on a false way.


Fritts writes:

I am pretty new to this, so someone yell at me if it has already been 
stated...  but couldn't the HBP be Gryffindor?  JKR has stated that 
the first chapter was going to be the first in CoS, so a back story 
on the 4 founders of the school seems reasonable.  There was a lot of 
talk in that book about the founders, more about Slytherin and his 
cool monster than Godric, but still.  Just a thought...

--Fritts
trying out this internet thing










More information about the HPforGrownups archive