A question on Sirius and his vault - Hagrid, Molly, Harry, Goblins
finwitch
finwitch at yahoo.com
Thu Mar 31 14:55:23 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 126877
"Steve":
n:
>
> Here is the problem I have with this idea that Harry gave Molly the
> his vault key or some other official authorization off-page. In some
> cases, Molly does say before the fact, that Harry should give her his
> School Supplies List and she will pick things up for him. If there was
> going to be a direct and literal authorization by Harry that would
> have been the time for it.
Finwitch:
That was in Goblet of Fire, and it's the first time someone else is
doing Harry's shopping for him. The giving of the list and permission
is cut off (well, I'd say that putting Molly say that and Harry do it
in the next sentence would be clumsy). As for Molly doing the same
thing apparently on her own in the Order of the Phoenix, I'd say that
the permission Harry gave Molly upon leaving to the Quidditch World
Cup was still in force. Maybe Molly had the key (or whatever) when she
was arguing with Sirius, saying that Harry was 'as good as' her son.
Finwitch
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive