Isn't his real name Tom Riddle?(was Precious little to celebrate)
greenfirespike
feenyjam at msu.edu
Fri May 13 19:16:09 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 128870
Marianne said:
> > Everyone is scared to death of saying Voldemort, which I think
> > lends too much power to him in everyone's mind. Why, then,
didn't DD or the Order or the Ministry simply start calling him Tom
Riddle? It's rather a pleasant name, and not at all scary. Did
they really go through the entire 11 years not knowing his real
identity?
SSSusan said:
> One of the more interesting theories I've heard about this (and
wish I could remember whom to credit, darn it) is that DD hasn't
revealed the connection between Voldy & Tom Riddle because doing so
would *hurt* someone he cares about.
> The suggestion, IIRC, is that someone -- perhaps even Minerva
> McGonagall -- was married to Tom Riddle, might even have had a
> family, and that some of the WW knows about that marriage, whereas
> very few know that Tom Riddle became Voldy. So, to broadcast to
the WW that TR = Voldy might be hurtful to this woman/this family or
could tarnish their reputation.
>
> Far-fetched, I suppose, but still an intriguing possibility.
Greenfirespike says:
I don't think Tom married Minerva, cannon makes pretty clear that LV
(and thusly Tom) never experienced love. I am sure Minerva would
never enter into a loveless marriage, a foolish young love fling I
can see, but not a loveless one. For what it is worth, I think DD
and Minerva are married; or former lovers.
Perhaps DD calling LV by his birth name, Tom, while in the ministry
was twofold; first letting Tom know that DD is well aware of who he
is and who he was, and secondly letting the remaining DE's know that
their leader is a half-blood himself.
IMO DD didn't know that LV was Tom Riddle until the end of VWI.
Greenfirespike
As an aside, did anyone else notice this!?!
In FQA, about the book, JKR said is response to the question: What
education to children of wizards have before going to Hogwarts?
"Even Muggle-borns like Harry attract a certain amount of unwelcome
attention at schools by re-growing their hair overnight and so on."
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive