Lucius & the diary (was: Voldemort's recruitment)
kamion53
kersberg at chello.nl
Sat May 14 20:51:21 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 128927
SSSusan:
>>>I think, for instance, that his CoS diary stunt was all
about trying to play for his own power and not at all about
bringing back Voldy.<<<
Rebecca:
>> That's curious. What do you think he could have been trying to
do?
SSSusan:
> Any number of possibilities have been suggested:
<snip various possibilities>
> *Even, if one assumes that Lucius did understand the possibility
> that Tom Riddle could return, that Lucius thought it would be
> better to have a young, more-potentially-controllable Tom around
> whom he could mold and manipulate and *use* in his own rise to
> power.
kamion53:
I don't think Lucius was spontanious playacted to have a more
potential controlable Tom Riddle back by dumping the TR-diary in
Ginny cauldron.
I think it's a action well planned about 12 to 13 years before by
Voldemort himself, propably around the time he gets yeast of the
prophesy.
Voldemort is obsessed with conquering Death, and he had some 50
years time to build saveguards of all kind, one of the first is the
TR-diary. Another it the spell/potion used in Goblet of Fire. Malfoy
Manor as one of his bases with a whole arsenal of artifacts stored
is not that unlikely. In GoF Harry, the Enemy is crucial to the
return of Voldemort. I think in CoS he was too, not for restoring
Riddle/Voldemort to life, but for restoring him to full power. The
power/lifeforce taken from Ginny would be not enough to give
Voldemort the power he needed. After the first year at Hogwarts it
is clear to Voldemort and the Malfoy what a potential cauldron of
power Harry is.
Playing the diary directly into Harry's hand would have been stupid
Harry would have been very suspicious when something like that
suddenly appeared between his useless collection of Lockhartbooks
and he neither would have started writing his diary in in. He isn't
the diary-type.
As the one to play the diary into the victims hand Lucius is the
ideal tool, he is a predator but a snake in method... snakes lay in
wait before striking sensing the heat of their victims. And Ginny
radiates as much heat as a lighthouse that day.
I think Lucius didn't need much more of an order in the year before
Voldemort fall as: " when such and such may happen, use the
opertunity to strike, my slippery friend."
It is even possible that Lucius kept the diary-Tom Riddle informed
of what happened after the fall of Voldemort. I got the impression
that diary-Tom Riddle knew about things that happened long after he
made his diary. Some of that information is from Ginny of course,
but is the scenario of Lucius Malfoy writing in the diary and
getting direct instructions a strange one?
In that case the action of Lucius is even more consieus and direct.
Why else should he be visiting Knockturn Alley to sell " hot" goods
at a day Diagon Alley is crowded with peopel buying schoolgear for
their kids. I would have taken a more quiet day for showing up in
that neighbourhood.
Kamion53
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive