Kreacher feature
deborahhbbrd
hubbada at unisa.ac.za
Tue May 17 08:18:31 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 129060
<snip
<bboyminn:
<I still have a gut feeling that Kreacher is dead or soon will be, and
<I admit I resist Dumbledore killing him, or causing his death, none
<the less, I can see it happening that way.
<Right now, I'm leaning more toward the Kreacher dead by his own hand
<idea. That saves us a lot of sticky moral questions.>
Deborah, now:
Why would Kreacher kill himself when staying alive to cause trouble
would be so much more satisfying? Well, what about if he was acting on
the instructions of the Old Mistress, Sirius's screeching-portrait
mummy? She has had his loyalty and love all along, and one shriek from
her along the lines of: 'He was the only son I had left, he would have
seen reason in the end, he shouldn't have died' will dump enough guilt
on her faithful aged retainer that he'll take a running dive through
the Veil of House Elves.
Only snag is, given Harry's power as the POV character, when is this
to happen and how are we to know?
Deborah, waiting for July
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive