Riddle solved - congrats Renee!

[M.Clifford]

No: HPFGUIDX 129707

 
> 
> tinglinger
> =============
> If noone else was at Godric's Hollow to witness the alleged events
> that occurred there (in particular Lily's sacrifice which is so
> vitally important to the plot), then JKR violated the Omnipotent
> Observer rule of writing (i.e. a story must be verifiable in order
> to have validity.) 

> 
> SOMEONE ELSE was at Godric's Hollow at the time Harry's parents
> were murdered.
> 
> As for who .... 

Valky:
Before I speculate on who, I just have to ask for some clarificaton.
Can someone quote the specific unvalidated canon that violates the
omniescence rule?

As far as I can recall, a lot of the knowledge we have of the GH
events have come from Harry's faint recollection throughout the
series, Voldemort himself, and Dumbledore wholly admitting that he is
making careful speculation based on things he has observed, such as
the scar, things that have happened with Harry and other various
clues, all the while also factoring in what he knows about James and
Lily. 

If there is a direction violation, then I've missed it. Good on JKR
for that, if it turns out to be the key, however I always believed
that the extra person at Godrics Hollow Theory was based on other
factors not this, so can someone help me get on the same page as
tinglinger etc

In any case, I still believe there is a huge probability that the
person is Snape. OTOH the Longbottoms (who suggested that? its a good
one) could well be brought into this somehow. It makes sense to me.
Maybe both Snape and the Longbottoms were connectively involved in the
attack.

Just thinking out loud

Valky