No subject

[Bee Chase]

No: HPFGUIDX 142390

> colebiancardi wrote:
>
> I don't think DD had a lifedebt to Snape, nor do I believe Snape
has
> a lifedebt to DD.  Lifedebts seem to be a very strange nature - it
> isn't just saving the life of someone, it seems to be saving the
life
> of someone at a) great risk to yourself and b) so far, saving
someone
> whom you don't care about at all <eg>  At what point did DD or
Snape
> put themselves in great risk to *save* one another?  We haven't
read
> or heard about it, so I doubt that.  Harry saving Ginny in CoS did
> not result in Ginny owning a lifedebt to Harry.  The only lifedebts
> JKR speaks of is Snape to James and Peter to Harry.
>
> I actually believe that Draco owes Snape a lifedebt now - after the
> UV and all.  If, of course, the UV supercedes lifedebts, as if you
> break the UV, you will die yourself(isn't that at great risk to
> yourself?<big g>).  I wonder if a UV cancels out lifedebts....hmmmm
>
> Luckdragon:
>
> I do not think Snape owes a lifedebt to DD. But if OFH Snape saved
DD. I think he would be at risk if LV found out, and if he is OFH he
would not likely really have feelings for DD, therefore DD may have
owed Snape a lifedebt. I think the idea that a lifedebt is only
created in a situation where the person saves someone he dislikes at
great personal risk is a very interesting idea.


		
---------------------------------
Find your next car at Yahoo! Canada Autos

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]