Not getting this one.....
Miles
xmilesx at gmx.de
Sun Nov 20 02:16:47 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 143248
Jen Reese wrote:
<snip>
> Wouldn't it actually be anger at Voldemort for killing his parents
> that keeps Harry from joining him (and anger at Snape as time goes
> on)?
Miles:
Yes and no. Would he hate Voldemort for killing his parents without loving
them so deeply? Would he love them so purely without having lost them at the
age of one?
Just take Sirius as a contrast - would he hate someone for killing his
parents? ;)
Jen Reese
> I suddenly feel like I'm missing something big, or there's a gap
> between what Dumbledore is saying and what his words actually mean.
Actually I think, that Dumbledore just doesn't tell Harry the whole story.
That is the gap you feel, and I do as well. Not only here, but in general.
About Snape hearing the prophecy (only the first part? the whole one?),
about the connection between Voldemort and Harry (the glimpse of triumph in
his eyes in OotP?), why he trusts in Snape and and and...
The relation of Harry and Voldemort will become THE topic of vol 7. And I
think, we will learn a lot about Dumbledores secrets, and some of them won't
be too enjoyable for Harry.
Expecting!Miles
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive