Shaken Dumbledore? Re: What does Slughorn knows about Dumbledore's injury?

[quick_silver71]

No: HPFGUIDX 143433

Carol wrote:
 
> This (natural) assumption fits with the cover story that Snape tells
> Bellatrix: DD is getting old, his reactions have slowed, and the
> battle in the DoM "shook" him (HBP Am. ed. 31)--this last statement
> being an out-and-out lie as far as I can see. <snip>

I actually disagree with the assessment that the battle in the DoM 
didn't shake Dumbledore. I think that it did...he certainly seemed 
frightened when Voldemort took control of Harry. 

Quick_Silver