Snape vs Fake!Moody (was:Bullying WAS: Re: Prodigal Sons)

[vmonte]

No: HPFGUIDX 141067

Betsy wrote:
It's precisely this sort of...hmm, I think hypocrisy might be too
strong a word, but there's definitely a disconnect here, that I just
cannot wrap my mind around. You seem to be cheering Fake!Moody on.
And yet, you also say you dislike Snape because you find his behavior
sadistic.

So, it's okay to repeatedly drop a child onto a stone floor from such
a height his body bounces off the ground, but it's sadistic to ask a
child a question for which he doesn't have the answer. Is it just
because the child being tortured is one you dislike?

vmonte:
What is your problem? I'm not saying that I like Barty Jr. 

What I said was that Barty Jr. knows that Snape is OFH. 

I never said anything about Barty Jr. being sexy, cool, a hero, etc. 
He is still a villian.

Vivian